Knight and Bishops, dancing around dots
(Eingestellt am 18. August 2024, 18:10 Uhr von bboom)
This puzzle is part of a series I'm making, exploring the odd anti-knight / even anti-bishop mechanic. Other puzzles in the series can be found here:
- First Practice (easy puzzle to try out the anti-bishop/anti-knight rule)
- Deranged scribbles or modern art?
- Knight and Bishops, dancing around dots
- Anti-Knight and Anti-Bishop Killer
- Bishops eat their sandwiches at 5:29
- Minimalist art or more deranged scribbles?
- Directionless Knights and Bishops
- Scribbled art in deranged colors
Puzzle rules:
- Normal sudoku rules apply.
- Odd anti-knight: Cells separated by a knight’s move in chess cannot have the same odd digit.
- Even anti-bishop: Cells separated by a bishop’s move in chess cannot have the same even digit.
- Kropki dots: Cells joined by a black dot must have a ratio of 1:2. All dots are given.
- Renban lines: Every line contains a set of consecutive digits in any order, without repeats.
Lösungscode: Row 8 (9 digits, no spaces)
Kommentare
am 4. Oktober 2024, 10:09 Uhr von bboom
Updated puzzle list
am 1. Oktober 2024, 12:15 Uhr von itsid
i found that to be hard (for me at least) the break in was quite difficult to get, maybe I was looking at the wrong thing though; anyways: nicely made puzzle, thank you
am 21. September 2024, 17:46 Uhr von bboom
Updated puzzle list
am 13. September 2024, 09:47 Uhr von bboom
Updated series list
am 7. September 2024, 17:33 Uhr von bboom
Added link to new puzzle in the series
am 27. August 2024, 20:45 Uhr von wacfwaef
koarla I think this puzzle was a bit harder but honestly just play with black dots, specially with the fact that only you can place 2 or 4 between 2 black dots that see each other (either by sudoku or by anti-bishop). The renbans are then to let you know which case it is.
I agree that it is more frustrating while you dont see that tip (along with box 1 restrictions) but after I hope it plays more easily
Hope this tip help with starting the puzzle.
am 27. August 2024, 09:55 Uhr von bboom
Updated series-list
am 22. August 2024, 19:33 Uhr von bboom
Thanks for the input koarla! I can definitely see that difference, and how a lack of a clear path can shift a puzzle from "challenging" to "frustrating" real quickly.
am 22. August 2024, 18:03 Uhr von koarla
Hey bboom, since you asked for a comparison between this puzzle and the previous one:
I think what made "deranged scribbles" more enjoyable is that the overall strategy seemed pretty clear (SPOILERS AHEAD) - first use the Palindrome lines to figure out even/odd, then use letters/colors to figure out which digits need to be the same by Sudoku and the two "anti"-rules, then use German whispers and region sums to figure out which letter/color is which digit.
I found it quite rewarding to have this clear path to follow, whereas in this puzzle it was less clear (at least to me) what I needed to be doing and where I needed to be looking, so I resorted to testing hypotheses quite a lot.
am 20. August 2024, 10:12 Uhr von bboom
Hey puzzlers,
I've noticed that the rating for this puzzle is a fair bit lower than my previous one ("Deranged scribbles or modern art?"). I'm pretty new to setting these puzzles, so I would love to hear what makes this one less fun/interesting than the previous one.
If you disliked this one, or liked it less, please feel free to comment about what made it less fun for you. I definitely won't take it personally, for me it is an opportunity to learn and make the next ones better!
am 18. August 2024, 18:42 Uhr von keenbowl
Very nice puzzle, thanks for setting&sharing.
Didn't even need the "all dots are given" rule for kropki dots.
