Logic Masters Deutschland e.V.

Divisible by 11

(Eingestellt am 3. Juli 2020, 16:50 Uhr von RockyRoer)

As a math(s) teacher, I've learned a lot of 'divisibility' tricks over my lifetime. You probably have learned some -- like numbers divisible by 5 end in 5 or 0. Or numbers that are divisible by 2 are even. You might even know that numbers divisible by 3 or 9 are divisible when the sum of their digits is divisible by 3 or 9.

There is a divisibility trick for 11 too, which lends itself to providing some sudoku clues. To check if a number is divisible by 11:

  1. Find the 'alternating sum' of the number:
    • Subtract the 2nd digit from the first...
    • Add the 3rd digit.
    • Subtract the 4th digit.
    • Add the 5th digit...
  2. If this alternating sum is divisible by 11 (0, 11, 22, or -11, -22...) then the original number is.
Examples:
  • An example: 84359 has an alternating sum of 8-4+3-5+9 = 11, which is divisible by 11, so 84359 is divisible by 11 (84359/11 = 7669).
  • Another example: 176 has an alternating sum of 1-7+6 = 0, which is divisible by 11, so 176 is divisible by 11 (176/11 = 16.).
  • Another strategic example: 379X has an alternating sum of 3 - 7 + 9 - X, or 5-X. To be divisible by 11, 5-x must equal 0, 11, 22, etc... If X is a sudoku digit, it would have to be 5. The number 3795 is divisible by 11 (3795/11 = 345)

Some observations that might prove helpful (the proofs are left as exercises for the reader):

  • If a number is divisible by 11, it will be in reverse order too.
  • A shortcut for three digit numbers: if the outside digits add to the middle digit, it's divisible by 11. e.g. 253 is divisible because 2+3 = 5
    • Note, there are some numbers like 319 that are divisible where this shortcut wouldn't work. You could still use this shortcut if you 'cast off 11's -- meaning subtract 11 away if the total is more than 11, e.g. 3 + 9 (-11) = 1

Short summary of the puzzle:

  • Normal sudoku rules apply.
  • Little Killer diagonals are shown when the cells taken as one number are divisible by 11. Numbers can repeat along these diagonals. Sorry/not sorry: only some sums are given.
  • Sandwich sudoku totals are given when the cells taken as one number are divisible by 11 (and not zero).
  • Many killer sudoku cages are shown, some overlapping. Every killer sudoku cage, when considering the cells inside as one number, is divisible by 11.Sorry/not sorry: only some sums are given.

Exercise for the reader (and helpful hint, so highlight text to show):

If you know the digits in a three digit number that is divisible by 11 sums to X, what is the middle digit?

Lösungscode: The two columns that are divisible by 11, in order from top to bottom (note they are marked with pink cages):


Gelöst von NikolaZ, cdwg2000, henrypijames, zorant, bob, Vebby, sanabas
Komplette Liste

Kommentare

am 26. März 2023, 11:50 Uhr von Vebby
Penpa+ link with answer check:
https://tinyurl.com/2jjtzyko

Zuletzt geändert am 5. Juli 2020, 06:26 Uhr

am 4. Juli 2020, 10:22 Uhr von henrypijames
Too many given clues - a bunch of them (more than 3) were left unused towards the end of the solve. I'm not sure if the rules mean to contain a negative constraint (if no clue given than not divisive by 11), but if so it should be dropped, and the number of anonymous boxes significantly reduced.

Reply: Thanks for the advice... I wondered about that... didn't mean to imply a negative constraint... just found a lot. Figured extra clues would boost confidence in solving, but could see how it might seem overwhelming too. I'll try a solve again and keep only the clues I found necessary to solve. I just find it really frustrating some times when I can't make any progress is a problem and figured the mathematical challenges here would keep people away without some sort of feedback that they were on the right track.... Perhaps I can make a second image of it with minimal clues given.

Schwierigkeit:4
Bewertung:N/A
Gelöst:7 mal
Beobachtet:9 mal
ID:0003SK

Rätselvariante Arithmetikrätsel

Lösung abgeben

Lösungscode:

Anmelden